Alberta Regulation Society tribunal to resolve on complaints towards Shandro after closing arguments

Article content material

Greater than three years after a heated confrontation in a physician’s Calgary driveway made headlines, a Regulation Society of Alberta tribunal will quickly resolve if former cupboard minister Tyler Shandro broke the lawyer’s code of conduct or not.

The panel that can weigh whether or not the previous UCP justice minister introduced the authorized career into disrepute in his interactions with 4 members of the general public throughout his time because the province’s well being minister heard closing arguments Tuesday.

Article content material

Article content material

Shandro is accused of breaching the Authorized Career Act on three events in February and March 2020, not lengthy after the federal government ripped up its grasp settlement with the Alberta Medical Affiliation. The listening to, which has taken place just about, started in January.

Shandro misplaced his Calgary-Acadia seat by solely 25 votes in final Might’s provincial election.

On Tuesday, Shandro’s lawyer argued the collection {of professional} conduct complaints have been politically motivated, whereas Ken McEwan, the Vancouver lawyer arguing the case for the regulation society, mentioned the incidents have been inappropriate efforts to silence political criticism.

McEwan argued Shandro’s behaviour represented a sample of intimidation.

“It’s that sample, that try to quell clearly respectable public debate by the varied communications, every of which was improper in its personal method, that’s incompatible with the most effective pursuits of the general public, or members of the regulation society,” mentioned McEwan.

Shandro’s lawyer Grant Stapon reiterated his argument that the complaints don’t have anything to do with Shandro’s regulation observe or skilled integrity.

Article content material

Article content material

“A single emotional outburst shouldn’t be the subject material {of professional} self-discipline,” he instructed the tribunal, citing a earlier ruling.

The collection {of professional} conduct complaints embody the allegation that Shandro “behaved inappropriately” when he went to the house of Calgary doctor Dr. Mukarram Zaidi and confronted him in his driveway over a social media submit.

A second criticism got here after two docs, then positioned in Purple Deer, mentioned Shandro used his place as well being minister to get their private cellphone numbers to contact them outdoors common working hours.

Additionally beneath scrutiny is when Shandro contacted a Calgary girl by way of his ministerial electronic mail after she despatched a criticism to his spouse’s firm, Important Companions, over what she believed to be a battle of curiosity. Alberta’s ethics commissioner has beforehand mentioned the difficulty didn’t require an investigation as a result of Shandro’s possession shares are in a blind belief.

The listening to committee’s resolution might be revealed throughout the subsequent three to 4 months.

Stapon mentioned it was telling none of these concerned filed the complaints that led to the tribunal. He urged the panel to keep in mind that Shandro’s household was being focused with threats on the time, when political tensions over the physician’s settlement and the recently-declared COVID-19 pandemic have been excessive.

Article content material

“These are all efforts to make an assault on Shandro’s political actions,” he instructed the panel.

Whereas McEwan famous that Shandro pushed Zaidi to in the end delete the social media submit that had sparked concern, Stapon aimed to poke holes in Zaidi’s model of occasions, and pointed to different associated social media posts.

“It is a personal dialogue in reference to what my shopper believed to be a menace to his spouse,” mentioned Stapon, arguing Shandro’s willingness to interact with the the 2 Purple Deer docs who had been “demanding to talk” with Shandro confirmed a willingness to interact with, somewhat than stifle, critics.

Nonetheless, McEwan mentioned each Purple Deer docs mentioned they discovered their interactions with Shandro to be intimidating.

“The minister of well being calling you off-hours in your personal cellphone conveyed the message, ‘I do know the place to seek out you, I understand how to get to you,’” mentioned McEwan.

Stapon admitted that Shandro’s use of ministerial electronic mail to answer somebody who contacted his spouse’s firm was “most likely misjudgment,” however was a personal interplay that had nothing to do with the observe of the regulation.

— With recordsdata from Jonny Wakefield

[email protected]

Article content material